Troublesome Knowledge

By Rose­mary Vogt, Teach­ing and Learn­ing Spe­cial­ist, CTLI

Trou­ble­some knowl­edge refers to infor­ma­tion or con­cepts that chal­lenge exist­ing beliefs, norms, or par­a­digms, caus­ing dis­com­fort, uncer­tain­ty, or cog­ni­tive dis­so­nance. This con­cept is often dis­cussed in the con­text of learn­ing, where stu­dents may encounter ideas that con­tra­dict their pre­vi­ous under­stand­ing or cul­tur­al upbring­ing.

Here are a few exam­ples of trou­ble­some knowl­edge:

  1. Sci­en­tif­ic Dis­cov­er­ies: New sci­en­tif­ic find­ings may chal­lenge long-held beliefs or soci­etal norms. For instance, the the­o­ry of evo­lu­tion can be trou­ble­some for indi­vid­u­als who adhere strict­ly to cre­ation­ist beliefs.
  2. His­tor­i­cal Real­i­ties: Learn­ing about his­tor­i­cal events such as col­o­niza­tion, slav­ery, or geno­cide can be trou­bling, par­tic­u­lar­ly for those who iden­ti­fy with the per­pe­tra­tors or ben­e­fi­cia­ries of such actions.
  3. Socio-polit­i­cal Issues: Dis­cus­sions around top­ics like sys­temic racism, priv­i­lege, or gen­der inequal­i­ty can chal­lenge deeply ingrained soci­etal struc­tures and per­son­al beliefs.
  4. Eth­i­cal Dilem­mas: Moral and eth­i­cal dilem­mas can arise when indi­vid­u­als are con­front­ed with sit­u­a­tions where their actions con­flict with their val­ues or beliefs.
  5. Cul­tur­al Dif­fer­ences: Expo­sure to diverse cul­tures and per­spec­tives may chal­lenge eth­no­cen­tric views and force indi­vid­u­als to recon­sid­er their own cul­tur­al bias­es.
  6. Per­son­al Iden­ti­ty: Explor­ing one’s own iden­ti­ty, includ­ing aspects of race, gen­der, sex­u­al­i­ty, or reli­gion, can be uncom­fort­able when faced with soci­etal expec­ta­tions or dis­crim­i­na­tion.

In edu­ca­tion, address­ing trou­ble­some knowl­edge requires cre­at­ing a safe and sup­port­ive learn­ing envi­ron­ment where stu­dents can crit­i­cal­ly engage with chal­leng­ing ideas. It involves encour­ag­ing open-mind­ed­ness, crit­i­cal think­ing, and empa­thy, while also pro­vid­ing resources and sup­port for indi­vid­u­als grap­pling with con­flict­ing infor­ma­tion or beliefs. Ulti­mate­ly, con­fronting trou­ble­some knowl­edge can lead to per­son­al growth, expand­ed per­spec­tives, and a deep­er under­stand­ing of the world.

 

Learn More